The Eve and John Conundrum

There came a point where I stopped bickering on a regular basis about how disheartened I was with the WWE Divas division. The wound on my forehead, acquired from banging it against a brick wall, would never heal unless I gave it time to scab. Reacting was always tempting. It stuck its middle finger up at me like smoking, sniggering, backpack-wearing teenagers on a school trip to London; beckoning one of the statuesque Queen’s Guards to buckle under the weight of their immature insult. This week, I snatched at that middle finger.

How did we get here? Why was it okay for the WWE’s top babyface to use derogatory language towards a woman, in front of children? We need to backtrack. The WWE is sitting on a goldmine in its Divas division. And yet, they refuse to plumb the depths of that mine to get to the good stuff. For a company so driven by profit, continually looking for the next big thing to keep fans interested, it’s just lazy economics. Why have a portion of your roster largely idle? The merchandising opportunities alone could be worth a fortune. I never understood why there were no LayCool t-shirts, for example.

There is a cycle of indifference at the heart of this problem. When it comes to long storytelling, indie wrestling matches can largely stand alone, and they’re no less enjoyable as a result. In the WWE, we need a sturdy narrative. We need verbal and physical dialogue that lead into the next week. We need peaks and troughs and, more than anything, we need to care about the characters. During the part of a show you care about least, you empty your bladder, or get something to eat, or chat to your mates. Enter the one-minute Divas match.

Give people a reason to care and they’ll stay in their seats. Come up with clever, forward thinking stories and the crowd will engage with the action. Trust that your female roster can perform as well as their male counterparts. Challenge them, and they’ll rise to it. If you work in a professional kitchen as a pot washer and stay a pot washer, you’ll never learn how to cook. But if the head chef gives you the opportunity to step up and be a part of service, you’ll acquire the skills you need to progress. It’s hardly rocket science.

Let the more experienced women bring the others up to their standard. Give them longer matches so they can learn from each other. The Divas aren’t all useless models, as so many like to suggest. The female roster is a mixture of indie graduates and athletes learning-on-the-job, just like the male roster. Beth Phoenix paid her dues in the indies, as did CM Punk. Eve Torres is a jiu jitsu expert learning the craft of pro wrestling as she goes. Dolph Ziggler was an amateur collegiate athlete who didn’t learn how to be a professional wrestler until he went to OVW. Nobody ever refers to Dolph as a model.

The WWE are like those people who buy expensive perfume and only use it on very special occasions. The rest of the time they just leave the bottle sat on their dressing table because it looks pretty. The Beth Phoenix vs Tamina Snuka match at the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view was like a gentle mist of CHANEL No. 5. Why not use it every week? Let’s have the best all the time. Nobody will ever  compliment you on the glass bottle you keep hidden away in your bedroom. Use it! Nobody ever compliments the Divas on staying out of sight. Use them!

At first glance, Eve Torres’s involvement with Zack Ryder and John Cena appears to be a small step forward. It’s a Diva taking centre stage in a big story. But the execution was less a dab of CHANEL parfum and more swamped in Britney Spears’ Midnight Fantasy eau de toilette. Its lack of class reeked to high heaven.

It is great that they wanted to give Eve a personality. It is great that they turned her heel. It’s great that she mixed with main eventers. It’s bad that they rushed the entire heel turn through in a matter of hours. It’s bad that, yet again, a woman is rarely made a villain in the WWE without her being linked to a man or without being involved in a superficial image issue. It’s so unbelievably boring, lazy and outdated. I wonder why Stephanie McMahon doesn’t make her team come up with something better. The answer I keep avoiding is that she may be her father’s daughter in the worst ways, as well as the best. It stings when your heroine doesn’t seem to represent the things you want her to.

Comparisons have been made between Edge and Eve. Edge did indeed use Vickie Guerrero’s position of power to serve himself. But the big difference there was that they were both the villains. The dramatic entertainment came in them slowly destroying each other. They deserved each other. Which leads us uncomfortably to John Cena.

Super Cena! Our hero. Children’s charity worker. Fighting the good fight, day and night. The role model. Setting the moral compass for kids everywhere. All this is what makes Monday night so upsetting. They made John Cena ‘that guy’. A lad. The most insufferable kind of man. Baseball cap on backwards, swigging cheap beer from a plastic cup, double-fist-bumping their buddies, bromancing about town and engaging in ‘the banter’. The kind of nauseating, testosterone charged chatter that some men partake in when they’re in the company of other men. The kind of banter where rape jokes are hilarious. The banter that allowed the offensive and now defunct UniLad website to operate. The lad culture that makes young rugby teams write lists of tour rules that allow cheating on girlfriends to go unreported.

With the language John Cena used towards Eve on Monday night, with his ‘skank juice’ and disease slurs, he aligned himself with ‘those guys’. The vocabulary made him sound about as eloquent as a Jersey Shore cast member. Yes, Eve was the villain, and yes, she revealed herself to be self-serving. But Cena’s reaction, while grinning, popping his Rise Above Hate t-shirt at the camera, and encouraging ‘hoeski’ chants, was hypocritical and confusingly out of character.

Much has been made this week of John Cena’s association with the Be a Star anti-bullying campaign. The initiative is a tricky concept to negotiate for a product based on people bullying each other. But it’s always seemed similar to the ‘don’t try this at home’ videos to me. They tell kids that any bullying they see on TV just isn’t cool in real life and explain that the bullies are mean characters.

The problem with John Cena is not only that he’s the number one good guy. There’s also such an extremely fine line between John Cena the character and John Cena the person, that any lapse of grace in either incarnation damages him somewhere. It’s not an easy place to be, but it’s the price paid for never being the bad guy, on-screen and in life. His choice of insults can’t just be put down to the script. WWE and its performers have to start accepting that they offer a unique, hybrid form of entertainment. It’s neither fiction nor reality and if John Cena is to set the example, he has to do it all the time.  They can’t ignore the impact his words might have on one sector of the audience to briefly win favour with ‘the lads’. Usually he thrives on not being over with that crowd.

In 15 minutes of television, all this succeeded in doing was making me wonder if by simply watching WWE programming, I’m trying to push a square peg through a round hole. Maybe this stuff just isn’t made for me. But I don’t want to give up on it. It’s easy to say ‘just leave it behind and concentrate on the indies.’ And I do watch and love a lot of indie wrestling. But they’re two very different entities. Both WWE and the indies offer things the other can’t, and when it comes down to it, I want to be around when the WWE’s penny finally drops.

8 thoughts on “The Eve and John Conundrum

  1. Wonderful piece, Rae. Clearly and thoughtfully laid out, and as usual you are bang on when discussing the Divas’ division. The Eve Episode shook me up a lot and led me to also wonder what the hell I’m still doing watching WWE. It’s nice to know I wasn’t alone. I really don’t understand why no one in the company seems to make the connections that you’ve made here.

  2. Great article! You summed up a lot of the thoughts I had on what happened. When I see something like we did with Eve and Cena, I do ask myself why I still watch WWE. The good outweighs the bad and like you, I wait and hope things will change. I also watch a number of Indy promotions and they fill the void WWE leaves in terms of quality wrestling matches and storylines. (BTW – I’m also a Chikara fan!)

  3. I’m sorry, but it sounds like you don’t get it. You are taking this WAY too seriously.
    It’s just a storyline. They are just protraying characters. This isn’t real life like how the whole Matt/Edge/Lita thing played out. If this was truly based off facts, I would understand the problem, but I don’t.

    This sounds more of a feminist post to me, and if that was what this post was about, mission accomplished. And before you think I’m against respect for women, don’t get it twisted. I was raised MOSTLY by women for 25 years, and I have a sister who I will protect at any cost. I don’t respect Chris Brown and would like to see him get his due. This wasn’t a problem during the Attitude Era, why is it now? If this is such a problem, then you might want to talk to whoever control society, because WWE isn’t the only one that has this “awful” mind process. BTW, I’m not so much defending WWE (as they have and still do some stupid, tasteless stuff that I refuse to defend them on, ), as I’m trying to make a point across.

    I fully respect your opinion, and by no ways are you wrong whatsoever, but I feel this is being made into something much deeper than it needs to be. Simple as that.

    • Chris, I agree with you. This is definitely a “feminist post”. After all, feminism is the pursuit of equal rights for women, and that’s the major issue here – the WWE simply don’t treat their female wrestlers with the same level of respect as the male members of the roster.

      The secondary argument that John Cena should know better than to take part in a segment encouraging a crowd to verbally bully a woman (all while proudly wearing a Be A Star patch on his sleeve) in the ring (albeit a heel) is a seperate matter, and one that cannot be simply excused as being “OK in the Attitude Era.” Times change, and so does acceptable behaviour. As Chris Jericho took a hammer to Chyna would that be OK now? HHH having sex with a corpse? Mae Young giving birth to a fake hand? The death of Al Wilson? Akeem the African Dream? There’s a reason that these things are cringeworthy when looked back on, and that they don’t tend to do this type of storyline any more.

      I agree that WWE is only a smaller part of society as a whole, but the fact is that they are a highly influential organisation with millions of viewers of all ages. As someone who was also raised primarily by women, and has 3 younger sisters, it’s not the kind of thing I would like them to watch. And I’d like to think that any group trying to push a PG product would admit with hindsight that they have missed the mark on this one.

    • What happens when all the storylines end up portraying women as emotionally incomplete, stark-raving mad morons? Wouldn’t you say that’s a problem? The fact that it’s a “feminist” post shouldn’t be what troubles you. The fact that Rae NEEDS to write “feminist” posts because WWE thinks women are cattle at best is what should alarm you.

  4. I’m with you, Rae. Bad taste all around. The problem is that if they had other good storylines going around the hoeski and the farts, it would be ok. When this is the whole showcase, it’s really bad. The “man’s division” is not made only of brodus clay and santino.

  5. This could be the most eloquent piece about the Eve heel turn that I’ve ever read. Well done to you, Rae, for authoring this. I agree/disagree with you on some parts of this, but I do not disagree with the fact that the divas deserve far more than what they’re given. They can’t hope to get better in 2 minute weekly matches.

    It kind of makes me wonder what they’ll eventually do to Maxine. I’d hate to see her go down the Hoeski line because she’s one of the best newbies for the Diva’s that I’ve seen in a long time.

Comments are closed.